Leadership is one of the most studied and debated subjects in the nonprofit sector. How do some people naturally command respect while others struggle to inspire? In his book From Transactional to Transformational Leadership: Learning to Share the Vision, Bernard Bass outlines three foundational ways that people become leaders. His framework continues to shape how we think about leadership development today, especially in mission-driven organizations like nonprofits.
Three Pathways to Leadership
Trait Theory
Sometimes leadership seems innate. According to Trait Theory—often called the “born leader” theory—certain personality traits naturally predispose someone to lead. We’ve all encountered people like this: a high school coach who inspires students, a scout leader who commands attention, or a boss who motivates effortlessly. However, Bass notes that this pathway is rare. Very few people are true “born leaders.”
Great Events Theory
Other times, leadership is sparked by extraordinary circumstances. A crisis, challenge, or pivotal event can transform an ordinary individual into an extraordinary leader. Think of community members who step forward during a natural disaster or a staff member who rallies a team during a financial crisis. These moments reveal and elevate leadership qualities that may have otherwise remained hidden.
Transformational Leadership Theory
The most widely accepted pathway today is Transformational Leadership Theory. This perspective suggests that leadership can be learned. With training, self-reflection, and practice, people can develop the skills to inspire, guide, and empower others. For nonprofits, this is especially significant: it means that anyone committed to growth can become a strong leader, regardless of background or natural disposition.
Respect Is Earned Through Action
When people decide whether to respect a leader, they don’t focus on titles or personal attributes—they watch behavior. Staff, volunteers, and donors look for signs of honor, trustworthiness, and integrity. They want to know whether a leader places the mission above personal recognition or gain.
Respected leaders are those who:
- Demonstrate honorable character in decision-making
- Remain flexible in both personal style and leadership approach
- Consistently prioritize the organization’s mission and values
At its core, leadership is not about the image of power but about service. Leaders earn respect by concentrating on who they are, what they know, and how they act.
What Makes People Want to Follow a Leader?
Employees and volunteers don’t simply follow because they have to. They follow because they want to. What inspires that choice?
- Respect: People want leaders who treat them with dignity and fairness.
- Reciprocity: When leaders show respect, they receive it in return.
- Vision: A sense of direction that is clearly articulated gives followers purpose.
In a nonprofit, where staff often work long hours for modest pay, the leader’s ability to articulate vision is particularly critical. A clear, compelling vision connects daily tasks to the broader mission, motivating people to continue investing their time and energy.
Why This Matters for Nonprofits
Unlike corporations that may rely heavily on financial incentives, nonprofits thrive on mission alignment and intrinsic motivation. A transformational leader who communicates vision, demonstrates respect, and embodies integrity can mobilize people far more effectively than one who simply manages tasks.
The good news is that leadership is not reserved for a select few. While some are born with natural charisma and others rise during moments of crisis, anyone can learn to lead. Nonprofits, therefore, have an extraordinary opportunity to cultivate transformational leaders at every level of the organization.
In the end, effective nonprofit leadership comes down to one question: are people inspired to follow you because of who you are, what you know, and what you do? If the answer is yes, then you are well on your way to becoming a transformational leader who can move both people and mission forward.
Contact Us
Please share your insights and comments with us on our Nonprofit Snapshot page on LinkedIn.