Small nonprofits are the backbone of community care. They’re often faster, closer to the ground, and more trusted by the people they serve. Yet when crisis funding becomes available, many small organizations watch the dollars flow to the largest, most well-resourced institutions.
If you’re a leader of a small nonprofit with a budget under $1M, especially in areas like food insecurity where demand is rising faster than resources, you’re not imagining it: the funding landscape is not designed with you in mind. The question becomes existential:
How are small orgs supposed to survive, build capacity, and grow when funders default to the largest organizations, even during emergencies?
Let’s break down why this happens, and what small nonprofits can actually do to compete, strengthen their footing, and change the dynamic over time.
Why Small Organizations Get Overlooked (Even When They’re Doing Critical Work)
Risk Aversion Drives Decisions
Large foundations want “guaranteed” outcomes. To them, a $5M+ organization looks stable, predictable, and safe. A $500K organization, even if more effective at direct service, feels riskier.
Admin Capacity Becomes a False Proxy for Impact
Big orgs have:
- Professional grant writers
- Fundraising teams
- Dedicated finance/compliance staff
This doesn’t mean they are more impactful. It just means they’re more prepared on paper.
Emergency Funding Follows Existing Relationships
When crisis hits, funders move quickly. They turn to the partners they already know can process funds fast. Unfortunately, that pipeline usually leads to the same few large organizations.
Small Orgs Are Expected to “Do More With Less”
Funders love your scrappy efficiency until budget time comes, and then the lack of infrastructure becomes a liability rather than proof of capacity.
Duplication of Services
One of the biggest barriers small nonprofits face, especially during crisis funding cycles, is the accusation of “duplicating services.” Funders often worry that too many nonprofits in one issue area create redundancy or inefficiency.
So What’s the Path Forward? Practical Strategies That Actually Work
This isn’t about optimism. These are tactical moves that small orgs have successfully used to change their situation.
Build a “Fundable Infrastructure Story,” Not Just a Mission Story
Your mission isn’t enough. Funders want to see:
- Systems
- Policies
- Financial controls
- Data tracking
- Proof of stability
You can be tiny and still show funders you manage risk well. Create a short, visual document called “Our Capacity Snapshot” that includes:
- Who you serve
- Annual impact metrics
- How you track data
- Your fiscal controls
- Your board makeup
- Partnerships
- Evidence of prior successful grant stewardship
Funders love this tool. It positions you as “small but sophisticated.” Shameless plug: I can help you create your org’s Capacity Snapshot.
Form Partnerships That Strengthen Your Position
Many small orgs break through by becoming indispensable collaborators in the ecosystem. Examples:
- Partner with a university for research or evaluation
- Formalize referral partnerships with other nonprofits
- Offer to be the “community outreach partner” to larger orgs
- Form coalitions specifically around emergency response
Coalitions signal credibility and reduce funder risk.
Join (or Start) a Local Collective That Speaks With One Voice
This is one of the most powerful and underused strategies. Small orgs band together to:
- Share data
- Submit joint grant proposals
- Advocate for equitable funding distribution
- Build relationships with foundations as a united group
Funders that won’t meet with you individually will often meet with a coalition.
Simplify Your Case for Support: Funders Need Clear Positioning
Large institutions benefit from name recognition. You can compete by being extremely clear about what makes you unique.
Examples:
- “We serve neighborhoods the larger food banks don’t reach.”
- “We fill the gap between SNAP lapses and emergency food distribution.”
- “We specialize in culturally specific food access.”
A sharp value proposition cuts through the noise.
Build a Restricted-to-Unrestricted Pipeline
Small orgs often stay small because their funding is too restricted. Shift your fundraising strategy to build:
- Monthly giving programs
- Peer-to-peer campaigns
- Local business partnerships
- Legacy giving awareness
- Board giving minimums
These create long-term stability and make you less dependent on crisis funding.
Ask Funders Directly: “What Would It Take for Us to Be Considered?”
Many small org leaders avoid this question from fear of rejection. But it’s one of the most powerful moves available.
Ask each foundation:
- “What would you need to see before we’re considered for emergency or multi-year support?”
- “What specific gaps should we address over the next 1–3 years?”
- “Are there capacity-building grants that can help us meet your criteria?”
Funders will often:
- Clarify requirements
- Flag opportunities
- Offer introductions
- Suggest pilot partnerships
Some even realize (because you asked) that their criteria unintentionally exclude small, community-based orgs.
Shift From “Underdog Energy” to “Essential Infrastructure” Energy
Funders should stop treating small orgs as side projects and start treating them as critical components of the safety net. But the messaging shift starts with you.
Use phrases like:
- “We are essential community infrastructure.”
- “We are a first responder in food insecurity.”
- “We deliver outcomes per dollar that outperform larger institutions.”
This reframes your size as an advantage, not a liability.
Advocate for Equitable Funding Models
You probably already know this, but it remains true:
Change happens when small orgs push for it.
Examples:
- Encourage funders to set aside small-organization pools.
- Advocate for equity-based scoring rather than scale-based scoring.
- Promote participatory grantmaking, where community members, and not only foundation staff, decide where dollars go.
Small orgs have successfully influenced funders this way, especially when voices join together.
Tell the Story Funders Aren’t Seeing
Large food banks may move high volumes of food, but small orgs provide:
- Trust
- Cultural connection
- Doorstep delivery
- Deep community knowledge
- Flexible responses
- Neighborhood-level access
Most large funders aren’t hearing this narrative. Tell it relentlessly.
Prepare an “Emergency-Ready” Grant Packet
When emergency funding opens, the competition moves fast. Have these ready to go at all times:
- 2–3 page organizational overview
- Key outcomes
- Financial summary
- Audited financials or compiled statements
- A list of partners
- A 1-page “Why small orgs matter in crises” case
Funders reward speed and clarity. Shameless plug: I can help you ready these documents in your rapid-response holster.
The Hard Truth, and The Hope
Download the Small Nonprofit Survival Strategies Checklist >>
The funding system is built to favor big organizations. This is real. But small nonprofits can break through. Your path forward is not to become bigger overnight. It’s to become:
- More strategic
- Better positioned
- More visible
- Better partnered
- More “fundable” in the eyes of risk-averse foundations
Small orgs that make these shifts see real movement. This does not always happen immediately, but sustainably over time. And your community needs you. Not the $5M institution across the county. You. Small orgs aren’t redundant. Small orgs are essential infrastructure that fills the gaps larger organizations leave behind. The more clearly you articulate this, the more funders will understand why you exist, and why you matter.
Download the Small Nonprofit Survival Strategies Checklist >>
Contact The Snapshot
Please share your questions and comments on our Nonprofit Snapshot page on LinkedIn.